John Bull takes climate change by the horns

We’re the ones with the Greens in Government, yet it’s Britain that has gone and set up a new department of Energy and Climate, headed by Ed Miliband. The UK is also to adopt a more severe target to cut greenhouse gas emissions by 2050, increasing this to 80% from its previous 60%. These are seriously ambitious targets that, to be delivered, will require no less than the re-engineering of British society.

Toughening up the targets was done in the teeth of intense industry lobbying to dilute the EU’s ambitious climate change plans, including tough carbon caps. Predictably, lobby groups for businesses argue that cutting carbon emissions will jack up fuel bills, but Miliband has stuck firmly to the line expounded in the Stern Review from 2006, and that is that the costs of inaction on climate change were far greater. Miliband’s next job is to set out exactly how this can be done.

“In tough economic times, some people will ask whether we should retreat from our climate change objectives. In our view, it would be quite wrong to row back”, said Miliband. His comments are a shot in the arm for EU leaders who have been battling to keep a December deadline to agree EU-wide energy and climate proposals on the table, and keep to a target to cut emissions by a fifth by 2020.

The spectre of a deep looming recession is making many in Europe, especially new members such as Poland (they of the large coal deposits) very jumpy. The emissions targets would apply to all six greenhouse gases defined under the Kyoto Protocol, not just CO2, as had been the case.

Concessions have already been agreed for some heavy industry and coal-dependent former communist countries. What’s most important about what Britain is now doing is that its government is making its new targets binding by amending its Climate Change Bill. Even the environmentalists, to date sceptical of much of the New Labour spin, are singing the praises of this new approach.

“In a decade in power Labor has never adopted a target so ambitious, far-reaching and internationally significant as this,” said Dr Doug Parr of Greenpeace. An amendment to Britain’s energy law being discussed would introduce ‘feed in’ tariffs for small-scale renewable energy generation.

These feed-in tariffs pay people a premium to generate “green” electricity and feed this back into the national grid, earning them a profit which helps to pay for installing solar panels, wind turbines, groundwater heating systems and other sources. Noises have been made in this direction in Ireland, but nothing so clearcut as this.

A couple of months ago, Gordon Brown was a political Dead Man Walking, now cometh the (economic) crisis, cometh the man. Clearly, for a leader well known to find environmental issue worthy-but-dull, he has had a Pauline conversion along the way. What hope our own Mr Cowen might follow suit? Two chances woul

Posted in Energy, Global Warming, Sustainability | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Half-baked Alaskan science bears closer scutiny

They say the first casualty in war is the truth. The same surely applies to elections, and none more so than the crucial US election on November 4th next. Republican VP candidate Sarah Palin has shown a startling contempt for science, as I previously reported in the Irish Times. Now we find that she and her officials in the Alaskan government drew on the work of a number of scientists known to be sceptical about the dangers and causes of global warming, to back efforts to stop polar bears being protected as an endangered species. Some of these same scientists were funded by the oil industry, surprise surprise.

In submissions to the US government’s consultation on the status of the polar bear, Palin referred to at least six scientists who have questioned either the existence of warming as a largely man-made phenomenon or its severity. One paper was partly paid for by oil company ExxonMobil. Continue reading →

Posted in Energy, Global Warming, Irish Focus, Sceptics | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Not watching the road

Today FM’s The Last Word yesterday evening featured two items with a climate twist, I was involved in one (a discusssion as to why, according to a UK survey, people who profess green credentials still engage in lots of long-haul flying) while Conor Faughnan of AA Roadwatch was in a separate discussion, this one around a planned crackdown on cars in Dublin city as a climate change measure.

Cars, Conor told us, are always being made the scapegoat. Carbon dioxide emissions? Pah, says Conor, every time you exhale, you emit carbon, so therefore you and I are pretty much the same as a car, ergo leave cars alone! He actually went so far as to suggest that a person exhales around the same amount of CO2 as someone who drives not that much.

Cars, for the record, on average emit FOUR TIMES their weight in carbon per annum, so a typical one ton car whacks up 4 tons into space for the next 50-250 years (OK, some of it ends up in the oceans, if we’re lucky). Cars are such a teensy part of the problem, says Conor, as coy as Michael O’Leary on a bad day, you couldn’t possibly pick on them. Go pick on houses, yea, they’re bigger again, and emit even more CO2. Anyone but my special interest group.

For the record, transport emissions, most notably from private cars, are far and away the fastest growing source of Irish CO2 emissions, having risen over 160 per cent since 1990, and continuing, according to the recent EPA report, to climb all the way to 2020. The AA really can do better than this if they want to be taken seriously as a lobby group.

Posted in Energy, Global Warming, Irish Focus | Tagged , , , , | 1 Comment

Eco nuts/clowns deliver a message to Michael

In July I wrote what I thought was a fairly measured article about the environmental impacts of our culture of low-cost flying. The main focus of the piece was on comments made by Aer Lingus boss, Dermot Mannion decrying EU efforts at making aviation pay a contribution towards the emissions it generates.

Reaction was swift and furious, but from Ryanair boss, Michael O’Leary, who seemed to have blown an entire gasket in fury at the above article. Two days later his now-famous response was published in the Irish Times letters page – littered with no fewer than 11 insults along the line of ‘eco-clown’, ‘eco-loony’, ‘eco-killjoys’, etc etc. Continue reading →

Posted in Energy, Global Warming, Irish Focus, Sustainability | Tagged , , , | 3 Comments

Sleepwalking across the climate ‘Red Line’

As of three years ago the Earth was already committed to rise of global mean temperatures by 2.4°C. This is the shocking conclusion of a new study in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS).

This is highly significant since the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has already warned that a rise in global temperature in the range of 1 to 3°C will lead to catastrophic consequences, including “widespread loss of biodiversity, widespread deglaciation of the Greenland Ice Sheet, and a major reduction of area and volume of Hindu-Kush-Himalaya-Tibetan glaciers. These systems provide the head-waters for most major river systems of Asia.” Continue reading →

Posted in Biodiversity, Global Warming, Habitat/Species, Sustainability | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Labouring under some misconceptions

What has meat go to do with climate change? At first glance, not a lot. But dig a little deeper and you’ll soon find that the sharp increases in meat consumption in the last decade or two is a major contributor to the problem of climate change and global warming.

The solution is that people should eat less meat to help combat the effects of climate change, that’s according to Dr Rajendra Pachauri, chairman of the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). He argues that people should aim for one meat-free day a week, before scaling down their consumption even further. Continue reading →

Posted in Energy, Global Warming, Irish Focus, Sustainability | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | 4 Comments

Getting the green message out is no Picnic

I gave the eco credentials of the Electric Picnic an enthusiastic write up in Thursday’s Irish Times column, describing it as “probably one of the most impressive environmental showcases ever assembled in Ireland”. The theme was taken up later that day on Today FM’s ‘The Last Word’ with Matt Cooper, when I and journalist Kathy Foley joined Cooper in a discussion on whether the Picnic was really just a good old-fashioned piss-up in a field, or could you seriously use it as a place to open a discussion about climate change, peak oil, etc?

As I arrived down to Stradbally in mid-Saturday morning, I ended up listening to a repeat of the radio piece in the Very Last Word, their weekend highlights show. It seemed like the right place to be hearing this; now all I had to do was find my way around the place (easier said than done, as it transpired) but I did manage to locate the ‘Rethink Tank’, a dome-shaped enclosure within the ‘Global Green’ area of the Picnic. Continue reading →

Posted in Global Warming, Irish Focus, Sustainability | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 3 Comments

The only way is up?

Today’s news report by Harry McGee in the Irish Times will come as a shock to those of us who had hoped against hope that the runaway carbon emissions train was at least being brought to a halt, whatever about being turned around.

Latest estimates from the Economic and Social Research Institute (ESRI) are that Ireland’s CO2 emissions shot up by 4.6% in 2007. These estimates have been developed by Prof Richard Tol of the ESRI using a mathematical model he developed. Continue reading →

Posted in Global Warming | 11 Comments

Dammed if you do, dammed if you don’t?

The McAleer/McElhinney bandwagon pulled into town on Thursday evening, with an appearance on TodayFM’s The Last Word with Anton Savage. The station had asked me to appear to challenge/counter some of his ‘global-warming-is-all-a-big-conspiracy-to-keep-you-poor-and-raise-taxes’ line of, for want of a better word, logic.

Click here to listen to TodayFM interview Continue reading →

Posted in Global Warming, Irish Focus | 9 Comments

Not Evil, just Cynical

Climate scepticism is good business indeed. Especially if you’re a struggling film maker anxious to make a quick name and buck for yourself. An Irish duo, Phelim McAleer and Ann McElhinney are the latest to hop on the bandwagon with their movie, Not Evil, Just Wrong – it is, we are told, “a feature length documentary which shows how extreme environmentalism is damaging the lives of vulnerable people, from the ban on DDT to the campaigns on Global Warming”.

If you thought Martin Durkin’s mockumentary, The Great Global Warming Swindle was a vile piece of work, step to one side, Mr Durkin, McAleer and McElhinney have composted a steaming pile of propaganda that would by comparison make Swindle read like a chapter of the IPCC’s Fourth Assessment Report. Continue reading →

Posted in Global Warming | 5 Comments

Thumbs down for Top Gear

The TV license currently costs €160 a year. That money allows RTE to deliver its public service commitment, including expensive programming such as Prime Time that, were cost and crude ratings the only consideration, might be ditched in favour of more Failte Towers.

The 100% commercial TV3 gives a clearer picture of what purely pay TV gets you – wall-to-wall US and Australian soaps during the day and imported soft porn later in the evening (still, at least they can’t be blamed for Failte Towers). Continue reading →

Posted in Energy, Global Warming, Irish Focus, Sustainability | Tagged , , , , | 4 Comments

Taking the Mick on aviation and climate change

A week ago my column in the Irish Times dared to suggest that maybe, just maybe, dirt cheap aviation à la the Ryanair model (now aped by our former national carrier as well) is perhaps not the world’s best idea from an ecological standpoint. Nor indeed is it such a smart move to consume more and more of our strictly finite (and diminishing) oil reserves in a binge of largely needless, prodigal flying.

Let’s be honest, there’s nothing remotely cheap about global aviation, other than the ticket prices. And since airlines dump a toxic trio of key emissions (high-altitude CO2, nitrous oxide and the manufacture of aviation contrails, which are also exercising a warming effect) without paying a penny towards dealing with this growing emissions mountain, maybe it might be time, whisper it, to consider getting the airlines to ‘fess up and pay up their share – no more, no less (and we won’t even mention the massive subsidies they receive in, among other things, tax free fuel). Continue reading →

Posted in Energy, Global Warming, Irish Focus, Sustainability | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , | 6 Comments

Whatever you do, do nothing

And so the G-8 Summit draws to a close in Japan. This Group of Eight major nations somehow manages to exclude from membership both India and China, which between them account for more than a third of humanity, as well (in China’s case anyhow) as the up-and-coming industrial powerhouse of the world. It’s quite the exclusive club, this G8.

Great news then that they took the massive step forward of promising to “do something” about climate change at some future point, ideally between now and 2050. This takes the form of a ‘long term commitment to halving emissions by mid-century. This has been described as a ‘shared vision’ – as ambiguous a phrase as any you’re likely to hear from the lips of a politician. Continue reading →

Posted in Global Warming, Habitat/Species, Irish Focus | Tagged , , , , , , , | 3 Comments

Only treehuggers need apply?

Once upon a time, the phrase ‘green’ implied wide-eyed extremism. You know the types, living in the trees in the Glen of the Downs or rolling in the mud at some bizarre eco hug-in festival in deepest rural Roscommon.

Yes, just as the Dutch wear clogs, the Swiss love their cuckoo clocks and the Irish are all violent alcoholics, so anyone who gives a toss about the world in which we live and which our children shall inherit is an unemployable treehugger. QED. Continue reading →

Posted in Energy, Global Warming, Habitat/Species, Irish Focus, Sustainability | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 10 Comments

Still singing the same sad old song

Denial is a powerful thing. Climate change deniers these days are, like the polar bears, an endangered species, as wave after wave of science fact gradually washes away the last stubborn traces of our excuses for inaction.

Of course, there are some folk for whom this whole climate denial lark is very good indeed for business. Bjorn Lomborg has spun not one but two complete works of science fiction out of the subject, and along the way, made himself a tidy sum, and secured his place on the happy-clappy lecture circuit for the foreseeable future. Continue reading →

Posted in Global Warming, Irish Focus, Sceptics, Sustainability | Tagged , , , , , | 8 Comments